Carnahan-Martin race hitting national radar

The Unablogger

The Unablogger

The re-election contest involving Missouri Rep. Russ Carnahan (D-MO) continues to receive national attention. Completing his third term in a safely Democratic urban-based district (Cook Partisan Index D+7) where President Obama beat Republican John McCain by 21 points, Carnahan’s re-election shouldn’t be on anybody’s radar. Except it is.

Late last week, the influential Cook Political Report recognized the contest as having enough upset potential to bear watching, one of 25 contests nationally to get a pro-Republican rating change. House analyst David Wasserman called this contest Carnahan’s “first tough reelection,” noting that Republican challenger Ed Martin started the year with nearly as much campaign cash as the incumbent. The contest’s rating is still “likely Democrat,” but this is the first step in the evolution of ratings changes. Note that several Republican seats that Democrats won in 2006 and 2008 were still rated “safe Republican” at this time in those years.

Martin released a web video on Super Bowl Sunday that also attracted national attention. NBC’s Political Director Chuck Todd’s ‘All the Right Moves’ blog reported the following day:

MISSOURI: Ed Martin, a Republican challenging Rep. Russ Carnahan for his seat, releases a dramatic-sounding Web ad branding Carnahan “Rubber Stamp Russ” and linking his image with those of Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid.

The video presents a compelling contrast of Martin’s conservative values and history of fighting for Missouri jobs with Carnahan’s lock-step support for the leftist agenda of Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Obama. As I blogged last July, Congressional Quarterly listed Carnahan as the congressman who supported Obama’s agenda the most, with a 100% rating, earning him the title “Rubber Stamp Russ.” Highlighted in the ad is Carnahan’s vote for cap and trade and a stimulus bill which awarded his own brother taxpayer money for a wind farm. It also points out his unwillingness to listen to the people of his district even at his own town hall.

The same day that NBC’s Todd took note, the Republican National Congressional Committee announced its recognition of Martin’s campaign as a Contender, the second stage of its Young Guns program. Martin had been recognized by the NRCC as “On the Radar” since October. He earned the promotion by exceeding NRCC benchmark goals for a successful campaign. These efforts included his Town Halls on healthcare and jobs, his meet and greets with voters of the district, and successful fundraising. Being a Young Guns “contender” may attract attention from national contributors.

Carnahan received negative national attention last summer when national cable news broadcast video of his gaffes in a health care town hall, as well as McArthur Bakery’s electronic sign protest of Carnahan’s vote for the job-killing cap and trade bill. Cable news also broadcast video of the mele outside another Carnahan town hall when Carnahan supporters from SEIU assaulted an independent vendor and a woman photographing the assault.

5 responses to this post.

  1. Posted by Nathan on February 22, 2010 at 1:48 pm

    Real Tea Party supporters will not be supporting Ed Martin for Congress. I don’t want another career politician and lawyer in congress. Many of the conservatives in the Missouri 3rd district will be supporting John Wayne Tucker for the republican nomination.


    • Ed is not only not a career politician, he is the real deal. Christian, Conservative, and all around true blue collar understanding with white collar titles. John Wayne Tucker is also a good gentleman, but is unfortunately not even a blip on the national radar and that is what it is going to take to beat a Carnahan.


  2. Posted by The Unablogger on February 22, 2010 at 2:12 pm

    Tucker seems to have the right conservative stands, but he lacks the gravitas to be a serious candidate. He ran two years ago and lost the primary to Chris Sanders.

    While it’s fair to be wary of people who have been in government before, I believe Martin “gets it.” He is a serious conservative, not a RINO. But primaries are for the party to sort out whoever is the best standard bearer. Let everyone make a case for himself/herself and may the best one win. After that, though, supporters of the unsuccessful contenders have to unite behind the winner of the Republican nomination.


  3. Posted by Nathan on February 22, 2010 at 2:20 pm

    While I disagree that Tucker doesn’t have the gravitas to be a serious candidate, (he barely lost to Sanders) I think everyone will agree to unite behind whoever is the winner. People are mad enough that many incumbents will be tossed out of office this year, I’d just prefer someone without political baggage to be the choice. May the best conservative win.


  4. Posted by SoCoNoJeCo on March 6, 2010 at 1:27 am

    Ed pissed off a lot of insiders, both Dem and Rep and the “controversy” is ginned up nonsense. Ed has drawn fire because he was effective in cleaning up some of the BS in our state. Tucker has no substantive critique of Ed, neither any equivalent accomplishments. He relies on repeating the lies and distortions of Ed’s political opponents. Whatever, dude.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: